Top export in trouble: Catherine Rampell on decline of international students in US schools

When you think about exports, the first things you probably think of are agricultural products such as corn and soybeans or manufactured items such as trucks or cigarettes. Did college degrees make your list? Not ours, either. Still, journalist Catherine Rampell, who covers public policy and political issues for the Washington Post, argues in this December 2018 essay that higher education is one of the most important US exports, and what’s more, that it’s in trouble.

Rampell, “One of America’s most successful exports is in trouble”

1. Why is the drop in international student enrollment a problem, according to Rampell? What is her argument? What evidence does she present? Is her argument persuasive? Why or why not?
2. Although Rampell mentions President Trump several times in her essay, she is neither overtly critical nor overtly supportive of him. Did her lack of an explicit position weaken her argument? Should she have taken a firmer position about him in one direction or the other? Should she not have mentioned him at all? Explain the reasoning for your responses.
3. Rampell begins one paragraph with “Boo-hoo, Trump supporters might say.” You won’t find that exact phrase in any of the templates in Chapter 6, but the message would certainly fit into one (or more) of the template categories in that chapter. Which category is the best fit? Why do you think so?
4. Do you think the United States should take measures to restore and promote international student enrollment in colleges and universities here? Why or why not? In light of your response to those questions, what policies might the state and federal governments develop in order to generate the result you support? Use Rampell’s article as your They Say and write an essay that argues your position.

Comments

[bradie holmes]

when you think about exports you are probably thinking about how a tangible good. However, it can also be a service like college. colleges are losing money when international students do not come over from other countries. Catherine Rampell says that they are not coming to college in the us and going to other universities in other countries due to our government. the numbers are there that these universities in other countries as our decline.